| John de Strathbogie 9th Earl of Atholl |
John "The Red" Comyn of Badenoch, Scotland (1269 - 1305) |
| Marjorie of Mar |
Joan or Johanna de Valence or Lusignan (~1269 - ) |
| David de Strathbogie Knt., 10th E. of Atholl | Joan Comyn |
| b. d. bur. occ. cen. im. . ud. |
b. abt 1290 d. bur. occ. cen. im. . ud. |
| Aymer de Atholl Knt., of Felton, Northumberland |